Title: Unravelling Domestic Violence as a World of Work Issue: A Feminist Analysis of Canada's Employment Laws and Policies
CLCW Visiting Speaker: Sofia Cornejo - Ph.D. candidate, Allard School of Law, University of British Columbia
Date: October 23, 2026
Unravelling Domestic Violence as a World of Work Issue: A Feminist Analysis of Canada's Employment Laws and Policies
This talk examines domestic violence as a workplace issue, exploring the relationship between violence and employment. Drawing on doctoral research, it reviews Canada's emerging employment laws and policies and considers how assumptions about violence, work and survivors shape the legal response.
Sofia Cornejo is a PhD Candidate in Law at the University of British Columbia, where she is expected to graduate in Fall 2026. Her research interests lie at the intersection of employment law and feminist legal studies. Her doctoral dissertation examines domestic violence as a world of work issue through a comparative analysis of emerging legislation in Argentina and Canada. Using a feminist lens, the study explores the tensions underlying the legal understanding and response to domestic violence in the workplace, including the conflict between ideal victim and ideal worker expectations, as well as the persistent notion that domestic violence is a private rather than a workplace issue. Sofia also holds an LLM from the University of British Columbia and previously worked for four years as a court clerk at an employment law court in Argentina.
Podcast:
Transcript:
00:00:00 Speaker 1
Hey, welcome everybody.
00:00:01 Speaker 1
Thank you so much for coming out today.
00:00:03 Speaker 1
I'm just going to begin by acknowledging that we are here today on the traditional and ancestral territories of the Haudenosaunee and Anishinaabe peoples.
00:00:12 Speaker 1
And I'm delighted to welcome our CEE Center for Along the Contemporary Workplace visiting researcher, Sophia Cornejo, to deliver a research talk this afternoon.
00:00:23 Speaker 1
Sophia is, I guess, still a PhD candidate in law, but she has successfully defended and is just waiting the conferral of that degree so that we can call for Dr.
00:00:33 Speaker 1
Cornejo at the University of British Columbia.
00:00:37 Speaker 1
Her research interests lie at the intersection of employment law and feminist legal studies.
00:00:43 Speaker 1
Her dissertation examined domestic violence as a world of work issue through a comparative analysis of emerging legislation on that topic in both Argentina and Canada.
00:00:54 Speaker 1
And using a feminist lens, her study explored the tensions underlying the legal understanding and response to domestic violence in the workplace, including a conflict between the representation of the ideal victim and the ideal worker, as well as the persistent notion that domestic violence is a private rather than a workplace issue.
00:01:14 Speaker 1
And that is what she's going to speak to today with us, pardon me.
00:01:20 Speaker 1
Sofia also holds an LLM from UBC and previously worked as a law clerk in the employment law court in Argentina.
00:01:27 Speaker 1
So if you can all join me in welcoming Sofia, we'll turn it right over to her.
00:01:36 Speaker 2
Thank you very much and good afternoon, everyone.
00:01:39 Speaker 2
Thank you for being here on a Friday with this beautiful weather.
00:01:45 Speaker 2
I am very grateful to the Center for Law and the Contemporary Board Plays and to Professor Bethany Hastie for having posted me during this last week as
00:01:56 Speaker 2
visiting a scholar and for organizing this talk.
00:02:00 Speaker 2
I am very happy to talk about my research.
00:02:04 Speaker 2
And also thanks to Lema and Natalie, who have been working behind the scenes organizing these spaces and events.
00:02:12 Speaker 2
So thank you, everyone.
00:02:14 Speaker 2
Today, I will be presenting part of my doctoral research that, as Professor Hastie mentioned,
00:02:22 Speaker 2
looks at domestic violence as a war-report issue, using a feminist analysis and comparing emerging and bond laws across Argentina and Canada, although today I will be focusing mostly on the emerging legislation in Canada addressing this issue.
00:02:42 Speaker 2
So next.
00:02:46 Speaker 2
So today I will start with a brief introduction of my research and clarification of some of the key terms I will be using throughout the presentation.
00:02:58 Speaker 2
I will then explain why I argue that domestic violence is and needs to be recognized as a workforce issue and walk you through how Canada has started to address this issue.
00:03:12 Speaker 2
I then on the second part will turn to the assumptions that underlie the legal understanding and response to this problem, particularly looking at the tension between the ideal victim image and the ideal worker archetype.
00:03:30 Speaker 2
And then I will finish with some conclusions and some ideas I have for future research projects.
00:03:39 Speaker 2
Next slide.
00:03:42 Speaker 2
So my research asked the question, the growth question that guides my research is how do employment laws in Argentina and Canada conceptualize domestic violence as a work or tissue?
00:03:57 Speaker 2
And I divided this growth question into two secondary questions.
00:04:01 Speaker 2
with the first one asking about how domestic violence emerged, how it started to be recognized as a work-work issue, and how the shift from seeing it as a private issue and related to work to considering it another to be addressed from foreign law has unfolded in each of these countries.
00:04:22 Speaker 2
And the second question asked about
00:04:25 Speaker 2
All these laws reinforce or challenge assumptions about violence at work and about survivors and workers.
00:04:35 Speaker 2
In terms of methods, I use a comparative law method and I conducted a few semi-structured interviews with representatives from trade unions and research institutions in both countries.
00:04:51 Speaker 2
In terms of theoretical framework, I drew families' legal theory and coercive control theory.
00:05:02 Speaker 2
Two key terms need to be clarified before we move forward.
00:05:08 Speaker 2
The first one is domestic violence.
00:05:11 Speaker 2
There are many terms that are used to describe violence
00:05:16 Speaker 2
and abuse in intimate partner relationships.
00:05:19 Speaker 2
And domestic violence has been strongly criticized among those terms, or among other reasons, conveying the notion that the violence belongs to the home, that it is experienced and must be addressed within the privacy of the home and apartment, which has led for a very long time
00:05:38 Speaker 2
to, and to some extent, continue to influence the states and institutions to intervene and protect women.
00:05:50 Speaker 2
And in the context that concerns my research, this notion creates a particular tension.
00:05:56 Speaker 2
It leads to ask how violence, that by its own definition is domestic, is concerned to the home, can be a workplace issue.
00:06:07 Speaker 2
And I use the term to expose that tension, to then make the tension explicit and then problematize it.
00:06:15 Speaker 2
But by domestic violence, I understand domestic violence in a broad sense as including coercive control, which is defined as an ongoing pattern of abuses that might not include physical violence
00:06:31 Speaker 2
and whose cumulative effects result in women's evolution of freedom, dignity, and autonomy, on what is often described as a feeling of entragment.
00:06:44 Speaker 2
The second term is work of work, and I also use the term workplace, but this term has a broad meaning.
00:06:53 Speaker 2
which includes the traditional physical workplace, but also includes labor that is performed in public spaces, in the home, and especially if used for like platform work in some cases.
00:07:09 Speaker 2
So why domestic violence is a work-work issue?
00:07:14 Speaker 2
So research on the intersections between domestic violence and work is relatively recent.
00:07:22 Speaker 2
It has started in the late 1990s, early 2000.
00:07:27 Speaker 2
In Canada, one of the most relevant studies was conducted in 2014, which consisted of a national survey on domestic violence and work that was conducted by the Canadian Labour Congress and Western University and revealed that about one in three workers have experienced domestic violence in their life.
00:07:49 Speaker 2
and that such experiences have not stayed at home but expanded into the workforce.
00:07:57 Speaker 2
Research reveals that domestic violence might have negative work-related impacts for workers experiencing abuse.
00:08:05 Speaker 2
These workers often report higher absenteeism, lower job performance, and in some cases end up losing their jobs for reasons connected
00:08:15 Speaker 2
to the violence they are experiencing by their intimate partners.
00:08:21 Speaker 2
This study, along with some tragic cases, also revealed that domestic violence can happen in the workplace, that incidents of domestic violence might unfold in the workplace.
00:08:32 Speaker 2
When perpetrators often continue harassing their partners, sending abusive messages while they are at work, stalking them, controlling them at work, and in some cases, showing up
00:08:44 Speaker 2
in their partner's workplace and assaulting them or their coworkers, which raises important risks for workplace safety.
00:08:56 Speaker 2
Working, having a job may also have important positive impacts for survivors.
00:09:03 Speaker 2
It provides financial security, which might be a critical part of survivors' strategies to resist and to rebuild their lives.
00:09:14 Speaker 2
It may also provide social connections and a sense of purpose and safety, although it's not always the case.
00:09:26 Speaker 2
I also argue that something that is generally overlook in existing literature, but it's important, is to consider how domestic violence and work are connected with the broader context of gender inequality.
00:09:41 Speaker 2
And bringing this gender inequality dimension into the picture could help to appreciate the multiple complex ways in which domestic violence and work are entangled in survivors' lives.
00:09:54 Speaker 2
For instance, it's my show how domestic violence can operate as a contributing factor of gender inequality in the workplace
00:10:03 Speaker 2
with a common tactic that abusers use to control their partners being preventing them from working, prohibiting them to work, or making them quit their jobs.
00:10:18 Speaker 2
At the same time, gender inequality in the workplace can contribute to domestic violence and to women's entrapment.
00:10:27 Speaker 2
For example, some workplace practices, norms and expectations that normalize or tolerate gender-based violence and discrimination in the workplace can, on the one hand, further entrap women by discouraging them from disclosing their experiences and seeking help in the workplace, and might encourage men to continue abusing their partners by sending a message that
00:10:54 Speaker 2
being aggressive, being controlling is tolerated and sometimes even encouraged.
00:11:02 Speaker 2
So how Canada is addressing this issue?
00:11:08 Speaker 2
I put here in the slide a timeline of how Canada has been addressing this issue through employment law over the last 16 years.
00:11:18 Speaker 2
So the first legal recognition to domestic violence dates back to 2010 when Ontario amended the Occupational Health and Safety Act to include domestic violence as a workplace safety risk.
00:11:34 Speaker 2
Then in 2014, the findings from the survey on domestic violence and the workplace were released.
00:11:43 Speaker 2
And that catalyzed legal reform all over the country, starting with Manitoba, which in 2015 was the first province to introduce domestic violence lip law, allowed workers to take a few days off work when experiencing domestic violence.
00:12:04 Speaker 2
Following Manitoba's lead, all provinces, two territories, and the federal government have already introduced similar legislation.
00:12:16 Speaker 2
In 2019, the International Labor Organization set an important milestone by adopting convention number
00:12:26 Speaker 2
190 on violence and harassment, which explicitly recognizes domestic violence as a manifestation of violence in the world work, a convention that was ratified by Canada in January 2023.
00:12:43 Speaker 2
Then moving to 2026, earlier this year in May, to be more precise,
00:12:50 Speaker 2
The UConn Human Rights Board of Adjudicators recognized for the first time that being a victim of domestic violence can be a potential ground of discrimination in the context of employment because of its connection to the protected characteristic of sex.
00:13:09 Speaker 2
The case is Anthony versus UConn University in this case.
00:13:15 Speaker 2
Anthony was contracted as an instructor by UConn University.
00:13:21 Speaker 2
And during her employment, she was experiencing domestic violence.
00:13:26 Speaker 2
And at some point, she took a week of leave because she was staying at a shelter and was unable to commute to work.
00:13:35 Speaker 2
She returned to work at the end of the leave period.
00:13:38 Speaker 2
And the following day, the university communicated to her that her contract was going to be
00:13:44 Speaker 2
immediately terminated and was not going to be renewed for a further period than she was expecting according to the discussion that she was having with her manager and with the university.
00:14:00 Speaker 2
Anthony brought a complaint before the Human Rights Board
00:14:05 Speaker 2
And as I mentioned, the board concluded that the university's decision, who imparted a change of direction to justify the decision to terminate the contract, was constitute discrimination and order to pay damages to Anthony.
00:14:23 Speaker 2
So there are other two cases that are pending decision before the Canadian Human Rights Tribunal and BC Human Rights Tribunal that
00:14:34 Speaker 2
deal with similar issues.
00:14:36 Speaker 2
So whether domestic violence victim status is going to be more broadly recognized as a potential ground for discrimination remains an open question now.
00:14:50 Speaker 2
So here is a more descriptive, more detailed description of how Canada is addressing domestic violence in the workplace.
00:15:00 Speaker 2
The provinces with the street pattern are those that have amended occupational health and safety law to include domestic violence as a form of workplace safety risk.
00:15:14 Speaker 2
And all provinces and territories except for Nunavut have introduced domestic violence sleep law with the standard
00:15:24 Speaker 2
duration of leave being 10 days, including five days of paid leave, with Alberta remaining the only province that doesn't offer any period of paid leave.
00:15:38 Speaker 2
So I will now turn to the assumptions that underlie the understanding and response of this problem.
00:15:49 Speaker 2
So in my dissertation, I argue that the recognition of domestic violence as a world of work issue has been partial, and it's deeply embedded with assumptions about violence and work and about survivors and workers.
00:16:03 Speaker 2
Assumptions that in turn shape and constrain how the problem is understood.
00:16:11 Speaker 2
I structure my study along three sets of assumptions, the gender dimension of domestic violence, the public-private dichotomy, and the tension between the ideal victim image and the ideal worker archetype.
00:16:26 Speaker 2
Today, I will focus on this last set of assumptions, but I am happy to talk more about the other two during Q&A.
00:16:38 Speaker 2
So, the deal victim is a scientific construction that has informed and to some extent continue to inform and shape legal and social responses to domestic violence.
00:16:53 Speaker 2
It operates as a sorting mechanism, dividing good victims, I use quotation marks,
00:16:59 Speaker 2
from bad victims, where good victims are considered to be more credible and worthy of legal protection and support.
00:17:09 Speaker 2
I put here a passage from the final report of the Mass Casualty Commission of Nova Scotia that I believe clearly illustrates what the ideal victim image involved.
00:17:22 Speaker 2
And let me read it to you.
00:17:25 Speaker 2
So the quote says, But what is a true victim?
00:17:29 Speaker 2
It's someone that is going to be helpless, that is going to potentially be crying, will be shaking, will have some bruises, will really show that she's a victim.
00:17:42 Speaker 2
This is what we are seeing.
00:17:44 Speaker 2
This is what we are expecting.
00:17:46 Speaker 2
Police officers are not going to believe a victim if she fails to show that she is a victim, that she is victimized.
00:17:54 Speaker 2
So as you can see from this passage, the ideal victim is defined as passive, lacking any urgency, helpless, independent, visibly harm and emotional.
00:18:08 Speaker 2
The ideal victim image also involves some expectations.
00:18:12 Speaker 2
Good, real victims should lead the abuser, should promptly report and seek help, and should cooperate with the police and the legal system.
00:18:22 Speaker 2
Failure to meet those characteristics and expectations has negative consequences.
00:18:28 Speaker 2
Those bad victims are subject to greater scrutiny, disbelief, and often are blamed for the abuse they have experienced.
00:18:41 Speaker 2
In the context of labor and employment law, and more broadly in the organization and regulation of work, the archetype is the ideal worker, which according to Nedalski and Madison is defined as a person for whom work is always the first priority, unencumbered by care responsibilities.
00:19:03 Speaker 2
So in the literature, the ideal worker is often defined as a worker who is free from care and domestic responsibilities.
00:19:12 Speaker 2
But the concept involves also other characteristics.
00:19:16 Speaker 2
The ideal worker is also independent and authentic, is rational, is able-bodied, and involves some expectation.
00:19:24 Speaker 2
Those workers, ideal workers,
00:19:27 Speaker 2
should be fully devoted to work, to have no career interruption, and should work long hours.
00:19:34 Speaker 2
As with ideal big team, failure to meet those expectations leads to negative consequences, lead to stigma and penalization, with some of those workers being excluded from the workplace altogether.
00:19:49 Speaker 2
So
00:19:51 Speaker 2
Oops, let's see.
00:19:53 Speaker 2
What happens with workers who are experiencing domestic violence?
00:19:59 Speaker 2
So I argue first that the idea of victim and the idea of worker archetypes are in tension.
00:20:04 Speaker 2
As you can see from the description of each of these archetypes, they are defined by opposing characteristics.
00:20:15 Speaker 2
And the second argument is that this tension creates particular challenges for workers experiencing domestic violence, often placing them in impossible positions.
00:20:26 Speaker 2
On the one hand, survivors might need to be recognized as real victims, as an ideal victim, in order to access legal support and protection, but that might harm them at work.
00:20:39 Speaker 2
They might then be stigmatized, be treated differently by their coworkers and employers, or may even lose their jobs, as the case of Anthony versus UConn University illustrates.
00:20:54 Speaker 2
And on the other hand, performing as an ideal worker might be weaponized against survivors to put their credibility under question.
00:21:05 Speaker 2
invoking narrative that as she was working, she has financial independence, so she must be lying.
00:21:13 Speaker 2
She must not have experienced the abuse that she said she experienced or the trauma she said she experienced, because otherwise why did not she live?
00:21:23 Speaker 2
So those expectations might be brought out.
00:21:30 Speaker 2
So it also poses difficult, poses survivors in a difficult position in the workplace where they might be discouraged to disclosing their experiences of violence for fear to suffer some of this penalization.
00:21:46 Speaker 2
And therefore they might be discouraged from using domestic violence leave or any protections or supports that might be available in the workplace.
00:21:57 Speaker 2
So I asked then, how do domestic violence live loss navigate this tension?
00:22:04 Speaker 2
And what I found is an ambivalence.
00:22:07 Speaker 2
I found that on the one hand, domestic violence live loss in some regards reinforce some of the ideal victim expectations.
00:22:19 Speaker 2
particularly through the verification requirements.
00:22:22 Speaker 2
So to access domestic violence sleep, workers have to provide some evidence, have to prove that they are experiencing domestic violence and that they need time of work for reasons connected with that experience of abuse.
00:22:38 Speaker 2
And this opened up the door for employers to rely on stereotypical expectation about survivors,
00:22:45 Speaker 2
and require evidence that reinforces those stereotypical expectations I was mentioning before.
00:22:54 Speaker 2
To require, for example, them to prove that they have reported the violence to the police or that they have initiated legal actions against the perpetrator.
00:23:08 Speaker 2
while at the same time neglecting the well-documented fact that survivors in most cases do not report and that there are many reasons why they do not trust the legal and criminal system.
00:23:23 Speaker 2
So verification requirements create this risk for ideal victim stereotypes to play out.
00:23:31 Speaker 2
And this is more problematic in Argentina than in Canada, because in Argentina, in most cases, it is mandatory.
00:23:39 Speaker 2
In most provinces and jurisdictions, it is mandatory to provide this evidence.
00:23:45 Speaker 2
And some provinces explicitly stipulate that the worker has to provide the document issued by the police, a court, or a medical doctor.
00:23:55 Speaker 2
So clearly reinforcing those stereotypical expectations.
00:24:00 Speaker 2
In Canada, in most cases, it is non-mandatory to provide evidence, but it depends on the employer whether they are going to require it or not.
00:24:09 Speaker 2
And in most cases, in most jurisdictions, it is unclear what type of evidence can be required.
00:24:17 Speaker 2
The law also stipulates that it must be reasonable in the circumstances, which still leaves the door open for employers to require this kind of problematic.
00:24:30 Speaker 2
evidence.
00:24:32 Speaker 2
As a way out of those issues or to mitigate those risks, a potential avenue could be to eliminate the verification requirements altogether to amend domestic violence sleep legislation and to eliminate those requirements or to prohibit employers from requiring any type of evidence as UConn already does.
00:24:58 Speaker 2
or to prohibit employers from requiring specific evidence that is particularly problematic as it connects with these stereotypical assumptions.
00:25:12 Speaker 2
At the same time, domestic violent sleep laws in other regards privilege the idea of worker archetype.
00:25:20 Speaker 2
And they do so through what I call the fixing expectation that is embedded in domestic violence sleep.
00:25:29 Speaker 2
And it consists on the expectation that survivors will take 5, 10 days of work, will deal with the abuser, will recover, will leave the pain behind, and come back to work being fully fixed and able to perform as ideal workers.
00:25:46 Speaker 2
And the problem with this expectation is that for many survivors it is unrealistic and it misses the temporal complexity of the experiences of domestic violence, especially with when we conceptualize it broadly as including coercive control.
00:26:04 Speaker 2
Research shows that coercive controlling abuses
00:26:08 Speaker 2
often expand for a very long period of time, sometimes for several years, and cumulative harmful effects are also experienced for a very long period of time.
00:26:24 Speaker 2
Suspecting that survivors would take 5, 10 days and then will be ready to work as ideal workers is
00:26:33 Speaker 2
often unrealistic.
00:26:34 Speaker 2
What might happen is that worker might continue having frequent absences, might need some types of accommodations, for example, might be afraid that the abuser might come into the workplace and attack them.
00:26:50 Speaker 2
So might need an employer to put in place some protections in order for them to be able to return to work safely.
00:27:00 Speaker 2
But employers are not required to put in place any of these accommodations.
00:27:06 Speaker 2
And as of today, there are not protections against discrimination for survivors in the workplace.
00:27:14 Speaker 2
So the employer might, if the employee continues to be frequently absent or continue showing a low shop performance, the employer might discipline them and even terminate their employment with just cost.
00:27:29 Speaker 2
And that is not going to be considered as discriminatory.
00:27:35 Speaker 2
So as some potential avenues to mitigate those risks, I suggest that domestic violence leave could be complemented with the right to request other kind of flexible work accommodation, especially considering also that someone
00:27:53 Speaker 2
workers might not need to take time off work but might need other types of accommodation in order to continue working.
00:28:02 Speaker 2
And what is especially urgent is to extend some protection against discrimination for workers who are experiencing domestic violence.
00:28:15 Speaker 2
So I conclude that the introduction of domestic violence related employment laws is a positive development.
00:28:23 Speaker 2
These laws challenge the notion that domestic violence is a private issue, is unrelated to work, to recognize it as a legitimate workplace concern, as a matter to be addressed through employment law.
00:28:38 Speaker 2
However, my research shows that the recognition of domestic violence as a war work issue remains partial and embedded in assumptions that shape and constrain the understanding of the problem and the response to the problem.
00:28:54 Speaker 2
Today, I focus mostly on the ideal victim and ideal worker archetype, showing that those stereotypical constructions continue to be influential
00:29:04 Speaker 2
in domestic violence sleep law, which in turn might hinder the potential of those laws to advance a more inclusive and supportive workplace for survivors.
00:29:16 Speaker 2
The tension and the continued influence of the ideal victim and the ideal worker might play out to discourage survivors from disclosing the violence in the workplace and from using domestic violence sleep for the fear of being stigmatized, punished or
00:29:33 Speaker 2
to lose their jobs as it happened to Anthony.
00:29:40 Speaker 2
I also identify some potential avenues to mitigate this risk, including eliminating verification requirements, complementing domestic violence leave with flexible work accommodation, and importantly, extending protection against discrimination to workers experiencing domestic violence.
00:30:01 Speaker 2
Which led me to my ideas for future research, where I expect to explore the gap in current legal responses to domestic violence as a war-forge issue in more deep and to examine the role of human rights law.
00:30:20 Speaker 2
So some questions that I'd like to explore are whether and to what extent current human rights law are well equipped or suitable
00:30:30 Speaker 2
to recognize survivors' experiences of discrimination in the workplace and provide them with adequate redress.
00:30:40 Speaker 2
I will finish here and I will welcome any comments or suggestions you have for my future research and to continue working on this project.
00:30:53 Speaker 2
And I will also be happy to answer any questions.
00:30:57 Speaker 2
Thank you very much.